WiFi Mesh vs. WiFi Extender: Which one is better for you?
WiFi extenders and WiFi mesh systems have basically the same purpose, which is to broaden your WiFi coverage, making the choice between the two quite a dilemma for those who are deciding to enhance their network. So, which one is better? It depends on some factors, and we are going to try to simplify it.
WiFi Range Extender
First, let’s talk about WiFi extenders since they were on the market earlier than WiFi mesh systems. Their goal is to stretch the limit of your existing WiFi coverage to the so-called “dead spots” in your home. These areas may not have a signal due to obstructions like concrete walls or maybe because they are already too far from the main router.
Here’s an example of a WiFi extender with our Amazon affiliate link:
How does a WiFi range extender work?
These pieces of equipment are typically designed for a plug-and-play experience. It is important to position them strategically to maintain a balance between proximity to the main router and the end device. Placing them too close defeats the purpose of extending coverage, while positioning them too far risks capturing a weak signal. Since they pick up and rebroadcast the signal from the main router, ensuring optimal signal strength is crucial. Also, their setup process is typically straightforward, where you just need to plug it in to a power outlet, connect it to the main router either wirelessly or wired, and then connect your end device. Once connected, your end device can now communicate with the extender, and the extender will relay it to the main router. This relaying can also cause some latencies, especially to the devices farthest from the router, if there are also several devices connected to the network.
Now, when it comes to connecting your end device, it’s crucial to understand that the extender establishes a distinct network with a unique SSID and password. If you have multiple extenders, you’ll need to switch networks and enter the corresponding SSID password initially. However, once your end device has saved the SSID and password, it will seamlessly switch networks as you move around, eliminating the need for repeated entries.
Another thing notable about WiFi extenders is their affordability. They are generally budget-friendly, making it more accessible to those who just want to expand the WiFi coverage of their homes or small offices.
WiFi Mesh System
Now let’s talk about the WiFi mesh system, which basically has the same goal as the WiFi extender but just has a different approach to reaching this objective. It’s newer to the market, as it’s essentially an attempt to enhance the traditional WiFi extender. This system has interconnected nodes that work together and promises to bring not only expanded WiFi coverage but also a consistent tune of internet connectivity, free from disruptions due to signal loss. In short, a more reliable internet connection.
Here’s an example of a WiFi mesh system with our Amazon affiliate link:
How does a WiFi mesh system work?
WiFi mesh systems usually have two or more nodes; these are the mesh devices that work together. So one node establishes a connection with the main router, while the additional nodes, just like the extender, have to be strategically placed throughout your place to form a seamless wireless network. Unlike the extender, these nodes operate within the same network, sharing a unified SSID and password, meaning there is only one SSID, so there is no need for you to enter different passwords even if you are connecting for the first time and moving around from one area to another.
In contrast to extenders, where connection issues with a specific extender can disrupt your entire connection, the mesh nodes that are placed in different parts of your home do not work independently. If one node goes offline or if there are disruptions in their functionality, the remaining nodes work collaboratively to reroute the traffic so as not to interrupt data transmissions. This is part of the self-healing mechanism of this system, which, in addition, continually monitors the status of each node and takes proactive measures to address issues in case a node becomes less responsive or fails to perform optimally. It also involves adaptability in responding to changing situations, such as the addition of new nodes for expansion or alterations in the radio frequency. All these happen in the background without needing manual intervention.
The WiFi mesh system setup
With regards to setting up WiFi mesh, it’s a bit more complex than the extender since it involves working with multiple nodes. However, most modern mesh systems are equipped with user-friendly mobile apps, which usually have a step-by-step procedure that is easy to follow in setting up.
Let’s also talk about scalability
Wi-Fi extenders can be added to the network, but their scalability is limited. Adding too many extenders can lead to network congestion and decreased performance. In contrast, mesh systems are designed to be easily scalable. Users can add more nodes to the mesh network to expand coverage without significantly compromising performance. This makes mesh systems more suitable for large or growing spaces.
In conclusion, both are effective in reaching their objectives. However, while Wi-Fi extenders are simpler and more affordable, Wi-Fi mesh systems offer a more robust and scalable solution, particularly for larger homes or offices with multiple devices and diverse connectivity needs. The choice between the two depends on factors such as the size of the coverage area, the number of devices, and the desired level of performance and convenience.
Check out these trendy and useful products via our Amazon-paid links: